- Infringement (section 29, Trade Marks Act, 1999) protects a registered mark; passing off is a common-law action protecting goodwill, registered or not.
- The test is whether the mark is deceptively similar and likely to cause confusion in the minds of an average customer of imperfect recollection.
- Reliefs include injunction, damages or account of profits, and delivery up of infringing goods.
- A suit can be filed where the plaintiff carries on business or resides, which is wider than the usual rule (section 134).
Infringement
- Needs a registered mark
- Use by another of an identical or deceptively similar mark for identical or similar goods
- Statutory right; no need to prove goodwill beyond what the use shows
- Dilution claim possible for well-known marks used on different goods
Passing off
- Works for registered and unregistered marks
- Proof of goodwill, misrepresentation and damage
- Evidence of reputation: sales, advertising, awareness
- Prior use can defeat a later registrant
What the court looks at
| Factor | Question |
|---|---|
| Visual and phonetic similarity | Would a customer with imperfect recollection mistake one for the other? |
| Nature of goods and channels | Are they sold to the same buyers through the same trade channels? |
| Class of buyer | Casual retail buyers are easier to confuse than careful professional ones |
| Overall impression | The marks are compared as wholes, with attention to the dominant element |
| Strict standards for pharma | Confusion over medicines carries safety risk, so courts apply a stricter test |
Defences
- Prior use of the same or a similar mark (section 34) — prior user prevails over a later registrant.
- Descriptive, bona fide use of one’s own name or of a term describing quality or origin (section 35).
- Acquiescence or delay by the owner, where the defendant built a business in good faith.
- The mark is invalid or liable to be rectified; the defendant can counterclaim for removal.
Remedies and forum
A typical enforcement path
- 01
Evidence
Registration certificate, proof of use and reputation, specimens of infringing use.
- 02
Notice
Cease-and-desist letter, unless urgency calls for an immediate suit.
- 03
Suit
Before the district court or High Court with jurisdiction, as a commercial suit; interim injunction sought at once.
- 04
Interim
Injunction, appointment of a local commissioner to seize goods and records.
- 05
Final
Permanent injunction, damages or account of profits, costs.
Frequently asked
Can I sue if my mark is not registered?
Yes, in passing off, if you can prove goodwill in the mark and a likelihood of confusion. Registration makes the case simpler and gives the statutory remedy.
Is a similar domain name infringement?
A domain name that imitates a mark can be restrained by passing off or infringement, and a UDRP or .IN dispute process is also available.
How fast can I get an injunction?
Where there is clear copying and urgency, courts can grant an ad-interim injunction on the first hearing; delay weakens the case.
What is deceptive similarity?
A mark is deceptively similar if it so nearly resembles another that it is likely to deceive or cause confusion (section 2(1)(h)).
Trade-mark case law develops quickly, including on the dilution of well-known marks and on keyword advertising. Confirm the current position and registration status before acting. Not a substitute for advice from an advocate or chartered accountant on your facts.