- A lease transfers a right to enjoy the property (Transfer of Property Act, s. 105); a licence only permits occupation and creates no interest (Indian Easements Act, s. 52).
- A lease for more than one year, or from year to year, must be by a registered instrument; an unregistered lease is inadmissible to prove its terms.
- The “11-month” arrangement is a convention to avoid registration and rent-control protection; courts disregard it if the document in substance grants exclusive possession for rent.
- Termination needs a proper notice; in a protected tenancy, eviction is only on the statutory grounds.
Lease
- Transfer of a right to enjoy immovable property for a term, for rent
- Creates an interest in the property; can be assigned unless barred
- Registered if for over a year or year to year
- May attract protection under rent-control law
Licence
- Permission to occupy for a purpose, revocable
- No interest in the property; personal to the licensee
- Registration not required, but stamping is
- Generally outside rent-control protection
The test courts apply
The question is whether the grantor intended to give exclusive possession for a term and rent. If yes, the document is a lease whatever it is called. Features that point to a licence include retention of possession by the owner, right to enter, limited use (for example only for a shop counter) and absence of a fixed term. Where a document is called a licence but gives exclusive possession, the label will not save it.
Registration and stamping
| Instrument | Registration | Stamp |
|---|---|---|
| Lease for up to one year | Not compulsory (a registered deed is still prudent) | Stamp duty by State schedule |
| Lease for more than one year, or year to year | Compulsory under s. 107 TPA and s. 17 Registration Act | Duty depends on term, rent and premium |
| Leave and licence | Not compulsory | Duty payable as an agreement |
Ending a tenancy
In outline
- 01
Check the status
Is it a protected tenancy under the State’s premises tenancy law, or a contractual lease or licence?
- 02
Notice
Serve a written notice as the lease or the Act requires. For a month-to-month tenancy under the Transfer of Property Act, fifteen days’ notice is the default.
- 03
Grounds
Where the Act protects the tenant, eviction needs a statutory ground — non-payment, subletting, bona fide need and so on.
- 04
Forum
Suit for eviction before the competent civil court; interim orders for deposit of rent.
- 05
Possession
Execution of the decree; self-help eviction is not permitted.
A rent agreement should cover
- Parties, property description and permitted use
- Term, rent, escalation and security deposit with refund terms
- Maintenance, repairs, utilities and taxes
- Lock-in, notice and termination
- Subletting and alteration restrictions
- Stamp duty, registration and the stage at which they are done
Frequently asked
Is a rent agreement for 11 months always safe?
It avoids compulsory registration but not the substance test. A long run of 11-month renewals with exclusive possession can still be treated as a lease.
Is GST payable on rent?
Commercial rent may attract GST if the landlord is registered, and residential rent to a registered business can attract tax under the reverse-charge rules. Check the current notification.
Can a landlord lock out a tenant?
No. Possession can only be recovered through the legal process; forceful eviction exposes the owner to a claim.
What about the Model Tenancy Act?
The central Model Tenancy Act, 2021 is a template for States to adopt; it applies in a State only if that State enacts it.
Rent-control law is State-specific and has been amended; stamp duty for leases changes with State budgets. Verify the current West Bengal position before relying on this note. Not a substitute for advice from an advocate or chartered accountant on your facts.