- The SHA binds its parties; the articles bind the company. Key rights (transfer restrictions, board nominees, reserved matters) should be mirrored in the articles.
- Since the 2018 amendment to section 58(2), a contract between shareholders on the transfer of securities is enforceable even in a public company.
- Founder vesting and leaver terms protect the company if a founder walks away early; deadlock and exit clauses decide what happens if the relationship fails.
- Where a non-resident is a party, pricing, put/call options and exit terms must also respect FEMA.
SHA, founders’ agreement and articles — who is bound
| Document | Binds | Typical content |
|---|---|---|
| Founders’ agreement | Founders among themselves | Roles, equity split, vesting, IP assignment, exit between founders |
| Shareholders’ agreement | Named shareholders (and usually the company) | Governance, transfer rights, anti-dilution, exits, deadlock |
| Articles of association | The company and all members | Constitution of the company; the place to embed transfer restrictions and board rights |
The Supreme Court held long ago that an agreement restricting transfer, if not found in the articles, does not bind the company itself. The practical response is to incorporate the SHA’s key provisions into the articles by special resolution, and to make the SHA prevail between the parties in case of conflict.
The clauses that do the work
| Clause | What it does | Watch for |
|---|---|---|
| Right of first refusal / offer | Existing holders get the first chance to buy shares a holder wants to sell | Time limits and pricing mechanism; avoid open-ended matching rights |
| Tag-along | Minority can join a sale by the majority on the same terms | Whether it covers indirect transfers |
| Drag-along | Majority can compel minority to join a sale to a third party | Minimum price floor and the consent threshold |
| Anti-dilution | Protects an investor’s percentage or price on a down round | Full ratchet vs weighted average; interaction with FEMA pricing for non-residents |
| Reserved matters | Decisions needing investor consent (budget, borrowing, new shares, related-party deals) | Keep the list specific; override of board authority under the Act must stay lawful |
| Board nominee | Right to appoint a director | Nominee’s duties remain to the company — see directors’ duties |
| Leaver / vesting | Founder equity vests over time; bad leaver forfeits or sells at a discount | Penalty-like pricing may attract section 74 of the Contract Act |
| Deadlock and exit | Escalation, mediation, shotgun or put/call, IPO/trade-sale | Valuer, floor and ceiling prices; arbitral seat |
Making it enforceable
- Adopt the SHA’s transfer and governance terms in the articles (and, for a private company, check the restrictions in the articles are consistent with section 2(68)).
- Stamp the agreement correctly for the State — see stamp duty and enforceability.
- Choose arbitration with a named seat and institution; interim relief in aid of arbitration is available under section 9 of the 1996 Act.
- Give the company itself a party role in the clauses that bind it (issue of shares, registering transfers).
- Where a foreign investor is involved, align pricing and optionality clauses with FEMA from day one; assured-return exit terms are generally not permitted.
Frequently asked
Do we need an SHA if we already have articles?
Articles are public and rigid; an SHA can carry commercial terms that the parties want to keep private and flexible. Most institutional investors insist on both, with the articles reflecting the essential rights.
Can a founder’s shares be forfeited if they leave?
Not automatically. Vesting and leaver terms operate through a contractual right to buy back or transfer, at a price agreed in the SHA. Terms that are plainly penal may be moderated by a court.
Is a drag-along enforceable?
Yes, where it is in the SHA and mirrored in the articles, and the transfer does not breach another law. The company and the transferees must register the transfer.
Does an SHA need to be registered?
It does not need registration with the Registrar for validity, but it should be stamped. Certain listed-company agreements must also be disclosed under securities regulations.
The Companies Act, FEMA pricing rules and stamp duty schedules are amended often. Verify the current position before signing; SHAs for listed companies are subject to SEBI disclosure rules. Not a substitute for advice from an advocate or chartered accountant on your facts.